A nursing home in California began playing music for residents suffering from dementia, and got responses from patients once considered unreachable.
There are thousands of nursing homes participating in an international music and memory program.
At Villa Coronado, a nursing home in San Diego, 10 residents with traumatic brain injury were given an iPod to listen to music. Over 4,500 residents in 300 California nursing homes are taking part in a statewide experiment. One of the aims of the study is to find out whether music can replace antipsychotic drugs and restraints for agitated patients. With some patients, it seems to work.
This patient population receives little or no therapy, and are mostly bedridden, isolated from the world around them. Researchers are looking to see if the music program can reduce aggressive behavior.
For some people, music brings back memories. It can help dementia patients become more aware of their surroundings. Music will bring a smile to some patients, and can calm those who are agitated. Some patients listening to the music will smile, move rhythmically, and be more responsive to their loved ones.
Music is said to activate more parts of the brain than any other stimulus. New research suggests music therapy could help people in a coma or in a vegetative state.
The patients’ response to music may even help physicians to diagnose consciousness. Studies show there is a high rate of misdiagnosis in vegetative patients, where it is important to determine a patient’s chance of recovery. Observing these patients leads some workers to conclude that rather than a steady state, there is a spectrum of consciousness, and patients drift in and out.
Caroline Schnakers is an associate clinical professor in the Department of Psychiatry at UCLA. Her research indicates there is a 40 to 50 percent error rate in diagnosing a patient’s consciousness. Some patients appear to be unconscious, and yet have some signs of consciousness and awareness of their surroundings.
A patient in a minimally conscious state (MCS) is considered to have more chance to recover than a patient in a vegetative state. If a patient is observed to be sometimes conscious, there is more hope of recovery. The diagnosis of a patient determines medical treatment and end-of-life decisions, so it’s important to diagnose correctly.
Some patients thought to be in a vegetative state are actually in a minimally conscious state, and they respond to the music. One nursing home activities director was excited to see how music affected the residents, saying they just come alive.
Researchers at UC Davis plan to have the initial results of their nursing home study by the end of this year. But regardless of whether music is able to replace medication, it’s worth giving patients music to improve their quality of life.
For more information on the care of dementia patients: Alzheimer’s on Guide To Long Term Care.